We invite scientists and educators to take part in the ongoing discussion about the scientific issues raised in Explore Evolution. If you would like to submit scientific comments or critiques about Explore Evolution, please send them in. We will review them and address them on these pages. For some particularly relevant comments or critiques, we will ask the author’s permission to publish their response, so please include your name, address, e-mail address and phone number with your submission to: furtherdebate@exploreevolution.com

« Reply to NCSE on Universal Genetic Code | Main | The NCSE's Biogeographic Conundrums: A Defense of Explore Evolution's Treatment of Biogeography »

Response to the National Center for Science Education's Review of Explore Evolution


In 2007, Hill House Publishers (Melbourne and London) published the first edition of Explore Evolution: The Arguments for and Against Neo-Darwinism. Designed as a supplementary text for High School AP Biology courses and freshman college biology courses, Explore Evolution was co-authored by two state university biologists, two philosophers of science, and a science/technical writer. Prior to publication, the book was peer-reviewed by a number of scientists and educators in various fields, and the book is currently used in a number of secondary schools and colleges. Praising Explore Evolution as "surprisingly rich for so concise a treatment," the reviewer for Kirkus Discoveries lauded the book for covering "an impressive amount of terrain... in a colorful and lively fashion" and for providing "substantive food for thought about natural selection and universal common descent."

The goal of Explore Evolution is to enable teachers and students to examine the evidence for and against Neo-Darwinism, the modern version of Darwin's theory. As might be expected, those who favor a dogmatic Darwin-only approach to teaching evolution have attacked the book. Unfortunately, their criticisms largely consist of straw-man arguments and ad hominem attacks that either misrepresent the actual content of Explore Evolution or the current state of biological science. Nowhere can this be better seen than in the online critique of Explore Evolution drafted by the National Center for Science Education (NCSE), a pro-Darwin lobbying group that has a record of misrepresenting the facts when it comes to criticisms of modern Darwinian theory and of smearing those who disagree with Darwin.

In the late summer and fall of 2008, the NCSE started posting a hodge-podge of articles on its website attacking Explore Evolution. Although available through the search box on the NCSE's website, the NCSE's articles attacking Explore Evolution had yet to be highlighted on the NCSE site by September of 2009. (Indeed, the table of contents page for the articles was still labeled "TempCritique.") By January 2010, the "TempCritique" label had been dropped. Unless otherwise noted, the responses below are to the NCSE articles as they originally appeared from the fall of 2008 through mid-September 2009.

Preface and Introduction
The "Creationism" Gambit
Evolution and Testability
The Definition(s) of "Evolution"

Universal Common Descent
Anatomical Homology
Anatomical Homology and Circular Definitions

Molecular Homology
Molecular Data and Phylogenetic Trees
Universality of the Genetic Code

Embryology
Haeckel, Darwin, and Textbooks
Genetic Toolkits

Biogeography
The NCSE's Biogeographic Conundrums

The Creative Power of Natural Selection
Misrepresenting the Galapagos Finches
Fact and Fiction about the Peppered Moth
Antibiotic Resistance Revisited
Response to the NCSE's Reply to Explore Evolution on Natural Selection

For additional information, see the Response to John Timmer.

Reference Cited
National Center for Science Education (NCSE). 2008. Critique: Explore Evolution, available online at http://ncseweb.org/creationism/analysis/explore-evolution.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.discovery.org/scripts/mt/mt-tb.cgi/16381

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Response to the National Center for Science Education's Review of Explore Evolution :

» Launch of Explore Evolution “Further Debate” Website from Evolution News & Views
Since its publication in 2007, the innovative science textbook Explore Evolution: The Case For and Against Neo-Darwinism has helped trailblaze a new way of teaching about evolution, one based on Charles Darwin’s own acknowledgment that“a fair result ca... [Read More]

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on September 10, 2009 5:08 PM .

The previous post in this blog was Reply to NCSE on Universal Genetic Code .

The next post in this blog is The NCSE's Biogeographic Conundrums: A Defense of Explore Evolution's Treatment of Biogeography .


For Discussion on the Debate